The Pillar

Home
About
News
Pillar Posts
Analysis
Interviews
Explainers
On Leo's Desk
Data
Pillar Columns
Starting Seven
The Pillar Podcast
Sunday School
Look Closer
The Pillar TL;DR
Conclave
—
Smoke Signals

Politics, secrecy and excommunication in a conclave — and before

Who is bound to secrecy, and when? And what can and can’t the cardinals talk about, even among themselves? And what are the penalties? It’s complicated.

Ed. Condon
Apr 28, 2025
∙ Paid

The conclave to elect a new pope is one of the most famous and famously secret processes in the world.

Image Credit: Vatican media.

But while most people know — or think they know — that promising favors and appointments for votes is a crime in canon law, and that no one can ever discuss what happens in the election process, the rules and laws are as detailed as the actual balloting process.

So who is bound to secrecy, for how long, and under what kind of penalties? And what can and can’t the cardinals talk about, even among themselves?

It’s a little complicated.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 The Pillar · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture