16 Comments
User's avatar
Charles Anderson's avatar

That’s because many/most Masses aren’t beautiful.

Joe Witkowski's avatar

My stopwatch was running for the loss of “beauty, beauty, beauty” to be blamed on Vatican II.

Open the floodgates please.

Charles Anderson's avatar

Meh. I don’t blame VII, but I do blame the “spirit” implemented in its name. I was born in 1980 and grew up with whitewashed churches, projection screens, bongos, roll-away altars in gymnasiums, and felt banners. Lucky to belong to a solid parish now with beautiful architecture and NO liturgies. Beige Catholicism converts no one.

Joe Witkowski's avatar

But all of our youth born 40-50 years after Vatican II miss that beauty that they never experienced… so is someone else telling them not to experience Mass now? I wonder who.

Charles Anderson's avatar

I think you’re conflating two different things. I’m not suggesting young people should reject the Mass they’re given, nor am I arguing that they need to experience pre-Vatican II Catholicism to appreciate beauty. Beauty isn’t a generational preference.

My point is that we shouldn’t confuse the validity of the Mass with the quality of its celebration. The Church has an extraordinary patrimony of sacred art, architecture, music, and liturgical tradition. Yet we’ve often settled for an aesthetic and liturgical minimalism that does very little to communicate the sacred.

I’m not sure why acknowledging that is interpreted as discouraging people from attending Mass. Quite the opposite. If beauty draws people toward religion, shouldn’t we be asking why we aren’t doing more to give them the beauty that is rightfully theirs as Catholics?

Dies Illa's avatar

I was fed Mass-slop growing up. Didn’t know any better, found it generally uninspiring.

Stumbled into actually good Masses. No one had to tell me the Mass was more beautiful, transcendent, less trite and bland. That was readily apparent.

Obviously, I have a preference for things that are better than things that are worse.

The same cannot be said for all generations…

Aidan T's avatar

Every single mass is beautiful. If you can’t see that, that’s a you problem.

Annie's avatar

This is objectively true, based on the reality that Christ makes himself present to us intimately and majestically in every Mass. Praise God that he has given us the gift of faith to believe that this is true.

But I think we can also agree that there are elements of physical and tangible beauty that are present in greater or lesser degrees at different masses.

Every meal I serve my children is prepared with love for them and concern for their physical and spiritual well-being. A dinner of (their favorite) roast chicken drumsticks will be received differently than, say, reheated leftovers from a few nights ago. Analogies are imperfect but maybe you see what I’m getting at…

Aidan T's avatar

I get that. It’s true the priest can be a doofus and the music can be cringe and the building a felt banger monstrosity and the congregation complacent. But I’m not having loose language when people start calling the mass ugly, beige or slop. Just not having it

Annie's avatar

Yeah. I think it’s a tough thing, because I totally agree with you, and there is virtue to cultivating reverence despite externals that are not as good as they could be. But then, it is true that beauty is fitting in the Mass, and affirming that truth is also good. It can be hard to keep affirming that without denigrating a valid Mass that is, as you say, objectively good and beautiful.

DF's avatar
3hEdited

Stopped reading at "conducted by Gallup". Gallup made a decision in 2012 to scale back and eventually stop polling elections because every time they did it showed their methodology was terrible. Then in 2026 they stopped publishing their presidential job approval numbers seemingly for the same reason, they were way out of step with virtually every decent political pollster and rather than admit they were very wrong, just decided to stop. They've now shifted to these more esoteric studies/topics/results because it obfuscates their methodologies have been terrible for the past 2 decades when phone interview started going out of style.

The Church would probably be better off blind than with this dataset.

RDB's avatar

Am I the only one whose reaction to these surveys is “Obviously, Patrick”? Those of us who have worked with young adults have known for decades that they are drawn to beauty, transcendence, and an authentic encounter with the living God. This is hardly a new discovery.

We also shouldn’t be particularly surprised that this desire does not translate into greater Mass attendance. That’s because this truth still hasn’t been discovered by the aging post-conciliar iconoclasts, as well as many bishops and priests who work hard to make sure to make the modern gerontocracy happy.

The real story is not a recent awareness of beauty by young adults. The real story is that those who have the ultimate responsibility for the liturgy actively make it very difficult to allow priests to offer liturgies that can communicate beauty and an encounter with the living God. Until that changes, the desire for beauty will not often translate into Mass attendance.

Sangiovanni's avatar

Somebody get this guy a mic in Baltimore so he can say it again for the bishops in the back!

Bob S.'s avatar
2hEdited

Is there a definition for what it means to be "spiritual" vs. "religious"? Religious seems to be easier to have a feel for, but I always wonder if the survey respondents' (presumably self-created) definitions of "spiritual" are so varied and wide-ranging that it makes the data suspect.

Cody's avatar

Religion is inherently connected to justice (giving your dues to the divine), so my intuition is that religious = disciplined observance of spiritual things, whereas spiritual = awareness of invisible reality. So, the Muslim who prays 5 times a day is religious, the hippie Enya mom who burns incense to "elemental spirits" every single evening is religious, but the lapsed-Catholic mountaineer who only thinks of God when he's having a contemplative beer on the summit is "spiritual but not religious"

Calvin Blick's avatar

I'm not so sure about these results...it seems likely that a decent chunk of folks would agree that finding beauty in religious spaces matters regardless of how important it actually is. Everyone is in favor of beauty. I have seen some pretty aesthetically undistinguished churches that were very full.