6 Comments
User's avatar
M. Manl.'s avatar

"On rare occasions, review boards have deemed allegations credible against priests who were later proven innocent. In those cases, a priest’s reputation may suffer long-term damage before exculpatory evidence comes to light. When this occurs, dioceses have a strict obligation to correct the public record and do everything reasonably possible to restore the priest’s good name and make amends."

The internet has created permanence of information that has never existed before and this is an issue that needs to be considered as well.

Ryan Ellis's avatar

Hey Billy, harassed any local Trads lately?

Keith Cummings's avatar

I don't think ad hominem attacks are called for in a Catholic context.

Keith Cummings's avatar

That is irrelevant. If you take exception to what he said, then you are free to express your reasons for disagreeing. If you don't, then you are free to express agreement or remain silent.

What is unacceptable is to launch on ad hominem attacks, then to double-down as if there is some great evil lurking behind his article.

You obviously have an issue with the author, but that is not germane to the conversation. You can either be charitable, or be quiet. Attacking someone's reputation in this context is, hmmm... exactly what this whole debate is about.

H Mohn's avatar

"In 2002 he received permission to return to the lay state..." The bishops' conference published the Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People in 2002. The implication is that the charter caused him to ask to return to the lay state. Perfect example of the Post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy.

The historical method of hiding/concealing abuse was an evil perpetuated by ecclesial authorities; however, it is also evil to publicly slander an individual's reputation when they cannot defend themselves (i.e. they are dead), or to answer the allegations prior to their publishing. One cannot commit evil in an attempt to correct a prior evil.